A Drop of Corruption by Robert Jackson Bennett

At the borders of the empire, contagions are abundant, and leviathans threaten the outer rings. The blood of those same leviathans is a key ingredient in magically transforming people to grant powerful abilities. Dinios “Din” Kol is one of those fortunate enough to have been altered. Due to his extremely enhanced memory skills, he has become an “engraver” and these skills are perfect in his role as assistant to Ana Dolabra, perhaps, the greatest living detective. And now, once again, the pair of them have been called in to solve what seems at first to be a straight-forward locked-room murder mystery.

As a sequel to “The Tainted Cup”, the first book in this “Shadow of Leviathan” series, this novel is simply amazing. Oftentimes, it seems to me, the second book in a series can be a letdown, especially if the first book was really good. But I am here to say any such fears with this author’s work have proven, once again, unfounded. In fact, this one gives us more in all respects. More plot, more character development, and much more world-building but in a way that doesn’t beat the reader over the head but rather lets it unfold as necessary to round out the various settings.

While Ana brings her genius for detective sleuthing, she is also an eccentric who prefers to wear a blindfold most of the time so as to not let her vision interrupt her thinking. Din’s perfect memory is ideal for interrogating suspects and witnesses and is able to “play-back” the facts verbatim if required. Useful in discovering discrepancies, to be sure. The murder mystery is off and running, but soon grows to something much more epic.

Author Robert Jackson Bennett has proven many times before that he is a master at building original fantasy worlds, demonstrating in-depth world-building with all the trappings you’d hope for. This is a rich world, with unusual circumstances, cultures, and motivations.

Many reviewers compare the mystery elements of these novels to a Sherlock Holmes/Watson experience, but I think a much better analogy are the works of Rex Stout. Here, Din is the fact finder, the one who goes out and about gathering evidence much like Archie Goodwin. We get most of the story from his perspective. Ana, like Nero Wolfe, largely remains behind and waits for the information to come in where she then analyzes, deduces, and brings her genius to bear.

The entire novel moves along swiftly as the original murder case grows to something affecting most of the known world. I loved discovering new abilities in other characters, engineered enhancements that I shall not divulge for fear of spoilers. This is “smart” fantasy to be sure, neither a D&D adventure nor a Hercule Poirot murder mystery. No matter what you call it, it is exceptional, and certainly a fun read. I look forward to the next book in the series, not only for another complex murder mystery but also to learn even more of this unique world.

Highly recommended.

(Note: this book is due to be published in April, 2025)

The Tainted Cup by Robert Jackson Bennett

At the borders of the empire, contagions are abundant, and leviathans threaten the outer rings. The blood of those same leviathans is a key ingredient in magically transforming people to grant powerful abilities. Dinios “Din” Kol is one of those fortunate enough to have been altered. Due to his extremely enhanced memory skills, he has become an “engraver” and these skills are perfect in his role as a new assistant to Ana Dolabra, perhaps, the greatest living detective. And now that the body of a high-level magistrate has been found, murdered by means of aggressive plants exploding from inside his body, Ana and Din have been assigned the case.

While Ana brings her genius for detective sleuthing, she is also an eccentric who prefers to wear a blindfold most of the time so as to not let her vision interrupt her thinking. Din’s perfect memory is ideal for interrogating suspects and witnesses and is able to “play-back” the facts verbatim if required. Useful in discovering discrepancies, to be sure. The murder mystery is off and running, despite the fact that both Ana and Din have secrets of their own.

Author Robert Jackson Bennett has proven many times before that he is a master at building original fantasy worlds, demonstrating in-depth world-building with all the trappings you’d hope for. This first novel in a new series proves it once again. This is a rich world, with unusual circumstances, cultures, and motivations. The reader is plunged into the middle of it all, but Bennett is adept at providing the knowledge necessary for understanding without resorting to massive info dumps that bog down the plot.

Many reviewers compare the mystery elements of this novel to a Sherlock Holmes/Watson experience, but I think a much better analogy are the works of Rex Stout. Here, Din is the fact finder, the one who goes out and about gathering evidence much like Archie Goodwin. We get most of the story from his perspective. Ana, like Nero Wolfe, largely remains behind and waits for the information to come in where she then analyzes, deduces, and brings her genius to bear.

The entire novel moves along swiftly as more deaths occur, and the danger level rises. Din discovers more about himself but his anxiety over his secret threatens to overwhelm him. I loved discovering new abilities in other characters, engineered enhancements like strength, amazing math skills, and another that I shall not divulge for fear of spoilers. There are numerous characters from all walks of life thrown into the mix and like many fantasy novels, the names are not common to our experience and can be tough to keep track of. This is “smart” fantasy to be sure, neither a D&D adventure nor a Hercule Poirot murder mystery. No matter what you call it, it is exceptional, and certainly a fun read. I look forward to the next book in the series, not only for another complex murder mystery but also to learn more of this unique world.

Highly recommended.

Callback for a Corpse by Teel James Glenn

Moxie Donovan is a freelance reporter and movie studio promotion specialist in 1930’s Hollywood. He’s married to a beautiful up-and-coming red-headed actress named Maxie. After the murder of one of Moxie’s sources, they find themselves embroiled in an old-fashioned whodunnit. Fortunately, they are able to move in the circles of the Hollywood movers and shakers but when further murders occur, they begin to wonder if they are in over their heads.

I’ve always been a sucker for early Hollywood mysteries, especially those involving a wise-cracking protagonist. So, I was prone to like this one coming in. It’s my first novel by this author but I can happily report he certainly turned in a fun and engaging story here. Moxie is the lead character and, indeed, the story is told through his first-person narration. He doesn’t shy away from shining the spotlight on his own foibles but his love for his beautiful bride, Maxi, doesn’t take a back seat to anyone, even when Moxie finds himself amidst many a beautiful starlet.

The author unleashes his extensive knowledge of early Hollywood and how it worked. He also sprinkles in a lot of cameos from real people, including Bela Lugosi, newly-minted Roy Rodgers, and many others that were less familiar to me. The dialog is snappy and energetic. Moxie, in many ways reminds me of characters such as Shell Scott, getting themselves into the deep end but always with a verbal comeback as sharp as a razorblade.

Looking forward to reading more in this series from the good folks at Bold Venture Press.

Moriarty by Anthony Horowitz

In the days following the disappearance of both Sherlock Homes and Professor James Moriarty at Reichenbach Falls, a new criminal mastermind has come on the scene. Clarence Devereux, a crime boss from America has decided to take over Moriarty’s criminal empire, filling the void. On his trail is a senior Pinkerton investigator by the name of Frederick Chase who joins forces with a Scotland Yard detective named Athelney Jones.

Interestingly, Jones appeared in the Holmes story, The Sign of the Four, but felt he came off in a bad light. Consequently, he has devoted the last several years of his professional life to studying the methods and techniques of Sherlock, himself, and so he now is quite good at the deductive reasoning approach.

This was a wonderful detective yarn, filled with great characters, a Sherlockian-style London atmosphere, and an evil menacing plot. It was like reading a Sherlock Holmes story even though Holmes wasn't in it. Our two protagonists, Jones and Chase fill the roles of Holmes and Watson admirably although neither quite meets the mold of their role models. There are also a number of other Sherlockian characters and references from Conan Doyles’ stories that show up including from ‘The Speckled Band’ and ‘The Red-Headed League’.

There is a huge twist at the end and even though I’ve read Horowitz before and even though I suspected not all was as it seemed, I was still caught up in a “Holy Cow” moment when it happened. It is important to note that this is an “fair-play” mystery, meaning it doesn’t cheat the reader out of any clues. All is there to be worked out on your own…it’s just that I had it figured wrong.

Yet another wonderful read from one of my top 5 authors of all genres. I’m glad he is so prolific because I want to keep reading his work for many years to come.

Dead Stick (Lucas Hallam #2) by L.J. Washburn

A couple of months ago, I read and thoroughly enjoyed Livia Washburn’s first book in the Lucas Hallam series, Wild Night. I knew I would return to the character and series soon and so I’ve made it a point to do so. There’s something about early Hollywood, the Prohibition era, and detectives that always stirs my soul and it doesn’t hurt when you have a high-quality writer behind the story.

This second novel is, I believe, even better than the first. Lucas, former Texas Ranger and current private detective (in addition to working as a stuntman/extra in western movies) is hired by a studio to determine what is behind some recent sabotage. It seems somebody doesn’t want the latest picture to be complete, perhaps because of the subject matter as evident in its title: “Death to the Kaiser!” The incidents of sabotage have gotten worse and may be aimed at one of the stunt pilots who just happens to be a former WW1 German ace.  But when a young pilot is killed, Lucas knows the stakes are high and the culprit(s) must be brought to justice. 

As in the first novel, this one seamlessly meshes the detective genre with that of a western novel. Lucas is an old cowboy and lives up to the high standards of hard, honest work while standing firm in the face of danger. A side plot surrounds his evolving relationship with his main squeeze, but Lucas gets the distinct feeling that may be headed in the wrong direction.

Looking forward to book number three.

Black's Beach Shuffle by Corey Lynn Fayman

Rolly Waters is a 39-year-old musician and has been playing guitar in bars, and clubs, etc. for many years now. Up until about five years ago, he lived the rock guitarist life too: booze, drugs, women…a sordid life all around. But a catastrophic event changed all that and now he’s sober. Still playing with his band. He’s good too, but not quite good enough to make the big time and earn enough dough for a quality life.

So, he’s taken up that age-old profession of private investigator. Usually, he’s hired to find lost children/grandchildren, obtain photographic evidence of marital affairs, etc. But now, out of the blue, he’s hired by a new-age dot.com style start-up company who has plans to make loads of money. However, seems they’ve lost (or had stolen) a key piece of hardware without which they’d be sunk even before the launch. Could it be corporate espionage? Revenge? Or something even more sinister?

I really enjoyed this novel. It’s cleverly written, well-plotted, and kept me interested all the way through. The setting of San Diego and, in particular, the infamous Black's Beach, is also well-handled. As a frequent visitor to the region, I recognized many of the city landmarks and I thought the author (a life-long resident) succeeded at what so many crime authors strive for: establishing the setting as a character in and of itself.

 

One thing bugged me somewhat, but not so much as to lessen my enjoyment of the book. The characters’ names are almost all derived from guitar brands or have tie-ins to the music industry. I picked up on this right off the bat when the character of “Fender” was introduced. Then when I met “King Gibson” I was on to the scheme. Now, I’m not particularly knowledgeable about guitars but I found myself looking up every name I came across and sure enough…names like “Marley” or “Simmons”.  Some names combine two brands, like “Curtis Vox”. A foxy lady is named “Alesis” (a music company), “Porter” and “Hayes” are a pair of insurance investigators. Even our main protagonist, Roland “Rolly” Waters” is a conglomeration of two brands. I suppose that’s all fine, but it smacks of being too cute. As I say, it bothered me some because it took me out of the narrative every time I met a new character and had to look up where their name came from.

This is a solid story with a well-thought-out mystery plot. The author’s own background in music really shines through in a realistic way. Other than their names, the characters are well-rounded and interesting, especially Rolly, who struggles to overcome his past choices.

Looking forward to reading the next in the series.

Home is the Prisoner by Jean Potts

Jim Singley has just been released from prison after serving a sentence for manslaughter. In deciding to return to the small middle-America community where everybody knows he killed his business partner, he knows it won’t be easy. As for the community at large and especially for those close to Jim and what happened, they can only wonder one thing. Why would Jim come back here? It must be for some sort of unfinished business.

That’s the mystery at the heart of this novel by Jean Potts, an accomplished writer of numerous short stories in addition to some fourteen novels published in the 1950’s-60’s. She is known for her characterizations, especially in small towns and that is clearly evident here. The plot unfolds through the eyes of a handful of people in Jim’s orbit, shifting the perspective and letting readers in on their own secrets and theories. From early on in the novel, one gets the impression that Jim was likely falsely imprisoned but at the same time it remains quite possible he is an evil man intent on revenge. The solution is not evident until the very end.

By today’s standards this is not a swiftly moving narrative. There is a lot of thoughtful perspective from quite a few characters, much of it inwardly focused. The novel is well-written and I can see why the author won the Edgar award for best first novel for Go, Lovely Rose.

The Humbug Murders by L.J. Oliver

Intriguing concept here: Taking place in 1833, Ebenezer Scrooge, at 30 years of age, acts as an amateur detective to solve the murder of his own boss, Mr. Fezziwig. I had high hopes for this novel, given the setup and they were mostly fulfilled. I especially enjoyed the character of Miss Adelaide Owen who comes to work as a clerk for Mr. Scrooge and demonstrates a keen mind along with a refusal to put up with the antics of men who feel themselves superior to women.

The authors work hard to insert Dickens references and characters throughout the story, not the least of which is Dickens himself in his role as a reporter. Also included are cameos by Mr. Pickwick, Miss Havisham, and the Artful Dodger among several others. In addition, there are plenty of new characters thrown in which have a major impact on the plot and who also seem like genuine (i.e. odd) Dickens characters. In the end the novel works well. I did not quite solve the case on my own but when the big reveal occurred, I felt I should have seen it coming. That's pretty much an ideal result for a mystery novel as far as I'm concerned.

Reportedly, this was to have been the first in a series. That seems unlikely now since one of the two authors behind the "L.J. Oliver" pseudonym, Scott Ciencin, passed away around the time of publication. (The other is E.A.A. (Elizabeth) Wilson). There do not seem to have been any more published since this one in 2015 either. That's too bad. I would have happily read the next and the next...

Wild Night (Lucas Hallam #1) by L.J. Washburn

Lucas Hallam used to be a cowboy, but the 1920s finds him in the role of private investigator. His beat is the rising acreage of Hollywood, complete with prima donna film producers, shady backlots, and plenty of greedy folks wanting to get in on the profits. But when an obnoxious firebrand preacher gets accused of murder, Lucas reluctantly takes him on as a client, despite his distaste for the man. Lucas comes to believe the man was setup but just who and why…well, the possibilities are endless.

L.J. Washburn has created an intriguing character in Lucas Hallam. He’s an authentic throwback to the stalwart western cowboys of the previous century, complete with a Colt 45 and a hunting knife on his hips. A former Texas Ranger and Pinkerton agent, he spends his spare time as an extra in Western pictures. He has all the skills required for dangerous PI work and plenty comes his way in the first novel in the series.

But despite the western trappings, this is actually a nicely developed mystery/PI yarn to be sure. I’ve always been drawn to old Hollywood and reading this book was just what I was yearning for. I found the characters to be realistic and their interactions fun to watch. Historical Hollywood stars like Tom Mix and William S. Hart make an appearance here and there which just adds to the fun. The mystery plot itself is sufficiently complex without being mind boggling, lending an air of intrigue with every page. Originally published in 1987, it is not surprising to learn that it won the Private Eye Writers of America (Shamus Award) for best paperback original as well as the American Mystery award. Quite an accomplishment for her very first mystery novel. Thankfully, Rough Edges Press has re-released it, along with the rest of the series in handsome new covers.

Above all, reading this first novel in the series served well to whet my appetite for more. As of this writing, there are two more novels as well as a collection of short stories so I can guarantee there will be more Lucas Hallam in my future.

Murder Knocks Twice (Speakeasy Mysteries #1) by Susanna Calkins

In 1929 Chicago, Gina Ricci is the newly hired cigarette girl at the Speakeasy known as The Third Door. It’s not her ideal job but she is struggling to earn money for her ailing father and so she casts her concerns aside and plunges into the job. But when she learns the girl she replaced was actually murdered, her concerns mount. And then a photographer, hired by the speakeasy to take pictures of customers having good times with celebrities, is murdered right in front of her. His dying words to Gina are to safeguard his camera at all costs.

I thoroughly enjoyed this historical mystery. The setting of a 1920s Chicago speakeasy was enough to draw me in and that setting along with the colorful characters and the page-turning mystery plot kept me reading right past my bedtime. Gina makes for a nice amateur sleuth, more the type that finds herself in a tough situation than the poking-her-nose-in-where-it-doesn't-belong type. The atmosphere was great, with the spot-on language of the depression, the ongoing prohibition enforcement efforts, all on the edge of the mobster scene. Various celebrities like Clarence Darrow, Amelia Earhart, Babe Ruth, and Lou Gehrig, and several references to Al Capone pepper the scenery. This is not a hard-boiled crime novel by any means but it's not exactly a cozy either. Everything was just as I hoped for when I first picked up this book and considered it to read.

This is the first mystery I’ve read by this author but I already have book #2 on my TBR list and may well pursue her Lucy Campion series as well.

The Golden Age of Murder by Martin Edwards

This non-fiction book won all sorts of awards when it came out in 2016, including the prestigious Edgar and Agatha awards.  It’s easy to see why.  I’ve dabbled in reading a few golden age detective novels, mostly Agatha Christies but a few others here and there. But I’ve never felt like I had a good handle on that era and how and why this sub-genre came to be so popular.  I was also interested in learning more about the authors involved.

The Golden Age of murder mysteries or detective novels is usually considered to be those years between the two world wars.  Big name authors were Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, G.K Chesterton (Father Brown mysteries), John Dickson Carr, John Road, Anthony Berkley, and many others. In the year 1930 a small group of these authors formed “The Detection Club”:

    an elite social network of writers whose work earned a reputation for literary excellence, and earned     a profound long-term influence on storytelling in fiction, film, and television.

This was a group of young writers from Britain (almost all living in London), whose impact continues to be felt even today.  This book focuses on their early years, from 1930 through 1949, which only involved a total of 39 members.   

The book does an excellent job of not only delving into their biographies and work, but also provides a solid understanding of how they influenced each other, criticized each other, and came to each other’s defense. I really felt like I got to know them, warts and all. Many of them got ideas from real-life murders, details to which we are also treated. But the real treasure here is in understanding how their work came to be so important and influential for later authors, whether in the mystery genre or beyond.  The author is, himself a crime writer as well as a noted authority on detective fiction which is very evident throughout the book.

Best of all, I feel like I absorbed all of the information that a textbook could offer and yet this doesn’t read like a textbook at all. In some ways, it is like reading a mystery story, especially considering all of the secrets these authors kept to themselves. Very entertaining to read.

The bad news is that I now have a whole list of authors I want/need to try and a much longer list of their books to get my hands on.

Highly recommended.

Too Many Cooks (Nero Wolfe #5) by Rex Stout

The fifth novel in the Nero Wolfe series finds Wolfe and his secretary/chauffer Archie Goodwin on a rare trip away from the brownstone on West 35th Street in New York City. Beyond his detective work, Wolfe is also something of a foodie. Given his girth and exuberance for eating, this is not surprising. Here, his culinary know-how earns him an invitation to a gathering of fifteen of the world’s most famous chefs. And of course, there will be a murder. This time, it’s one of the attendees, an irascible man who is literally stabbed in the back, likely by one of his peers. 

A side note: The story is set in 1938, a time of less-than-palatable racism. It can be an uncomfortable reading experience from today’s perspective, but readers must recognize the times for what they were. I’ve heard more than once that these novels, in general, are racist but I think it’s important to differentiate an accurate depiction of the era from purposeful prejudicial writing. In fact, the author, Rex Stout works to demonstrate how wrong these prejudices truly are, as evidenced by this comment from Nero Wolfe:

    “The ideal human agreement is one in which distinctions of race and color and religion are totally disregarded; anyone helping to preserve those distinctions is postponing that ideal…"

I’ve been wanting to read more of this series ever since I read book number one, Fer-de-Lance. I thought that one was OK but felt it was probably not the best of what the series had to offer. I searched through various top-10 lists and found that this one, Too Many Cooks was listed on every single one. I must say, I thoroughly enjoyed it. It has made me a fan of Nero Wolfe, Archie Goodwin, and of course Rex Stout. The mystery elements were excellent, as expected, and those who enjoy brilliant detectives should like it too. Happily, there is a nice amount of humor sprinkled throughout, as well.

And so, another lengthy series has been added to my ever-growing TBR list… Sigh.

Under a Veiled Moon (Inspector Corravan #2) by Karen Odden

1878

Inspector Michael Corravan, a senior officer at Scotland Yard now finds himself as acting superintendent at Wapping River Police for the past three months. As a man born in Ireland, orphaned at an early age and raised by the Irish Doyle family, it’s a tough time for him. He’s caught in the middle, working for the English crown while fighting down his disgust at the very active prejudice he sees against his own people across England.

But Corravan is nothing if not dogged in his police duties so when a body is discovered near the docks and found to be likely something more than an accident, he sets out to investigate. But soon his work is overwhelmed by a catastrophe upon the Thames. The pleasure steamer named the Princess Alice is struck by the massive Bywell Castle, an iron-hulled collier, resulting in the loss of most of the 600 passengers. All police are sucked into the effort to search for survivors and handle relief efforts. Local newspapers start reporting rumors and innuendos about the Irish Republican Brotherhood being responsible. A single case of possible murder appears to have turned into a complex case of mass murder for political purposes.

Karen Odden has once again written a wonderful, historically accurate novel of murder, intrigue, and deadly peril. For the first few chapters I wondered what she might have in mind for us readers as we get to peel the proverbial onion back on a society prone to prejudice and political activism. Sure, there was a what appeared to be a murder case and surely Inspector Corravan would investigate and uncover the truth of the matter. But then the whole plot took a deep turn into unexpected territory. The sinking of the Princess Alice is a historical event and many of the characters involved with her destiny and that we read about here are actual historical characters. This incident remains the greatest loss of life of any British inland waterway shipping accident in history. The author uses this tragedy and creates a masterful story of political intrigue around it, forcing Inspector Corravan to solve what amounts to one of the very first incidents of terrorism ever, even when it means working with sordid figures of the seedy London underbelly. And to think I thought this would be just a simple murder mystery.

I’ve read a couple of other novels by Karen Odden and have always come away impressed. She has a knack for creating complex plots and yet keeping them entirely readable. The settings, society, and true-to-life history reflect her in depth research. But, as in all good stories, the characters make the novel and here, Karen Odden has pulled out all the stops. Inspector Corravan is a superb character, filled with human foibles to balance out his honorable intentions. We get to see a lot of his adopted family and their destinies, heavily influenced by a decision he made long ago. Indeed, one of the central themes of the novel is how one learns to live with prior regretful choices.

This is the second of the Inspector Corravan novels and I will add that I have yet to read the first one. However, at no time did I feel like I was missing anything. The author provides any backstory needed so I was quite comfortable throughout. Of course, I do feel the need to go back now and read that first one (“Down a Dark River”), not to fill in anything about this one but simply to revel in the experience of reading a Karen Odden novel.

The Case of the Lucky Legs (Perry Mason) by Erle Stanley Gardner

Marjorie Clune is one lucky lady. Or so she thinks. She’s won a contest that has judged her legs to be the “best in show” and now she’s set upon a fine modeling and movie career. Unfortunately, it doesn’t play out that way due to the shenanigans of movie promoter Frank Patton who turns out to be a con man. Famous lawyer Perry Mason is hired to defend Marjorie, a job which gets much more difficult when he decides to visit Patton in his apartment and discovers his dead body.

This is the fifth Perry Mason novel I’ve read so I am by no means an expert considering there were 82 novels and 4 short stories penned by Mr. Gardner. However, I’ve sampled them throughout the series and it now seems evident that Perry Mason evolved quite a bit throughout the run. This is only the third novel published and, like the first two (which I also read), it depicts a much harder Perry Mason than the character we usually think of. He is a forceful and direct man, given to barking orders to everybody around him and expecting instant compliance. Even his utterly loyal secretary, Della Street, isn’t immune to his commanding nature. Often, soon after issuing a curt command to an associate, he follows up with “And make it snappy!”

This behavior can be a little off-putting for those who come to these novels only after absorbing the TV series starring Raymond Burr. However, it is consistent with the times in which they were written and with other series characters being published. He absolutely matches his own description as described in the very first book, "The Case of the Velvet Claws": “You'll find that I'm a lawyer who has specialized in trial work, and in a lot of criminal work...I'm a specialist on getting people out of trouble. They come to me when they're in all sorts of trouble, and I work them out.” In this novel he proves his mettle and even risks putting himself in severe legal peril. If his hunch is wrong he will be indicted for accessory after the fact…for murder.

But one thing does certainly remain consistent throughout the long run of the series: Perry Mason’s unerring ability to get to the heart of the crime, no matter how convoluted the scheme. These early books in the series don’t even include a courtroom scene. The case never gets that far. Perry acts more like a ferocious PI than a lawyer but his profound understanding of the law (thanks to the author’s extensive experience with more than 20 years as a practicing attorney) gives him a leg up on other PIs and police.

I enjoyed this one just fine, but I am hoping for the more traditional Perry Mason novels in my future reading. The best ones always include exposing the truth through piercing cross-examination on the witness stand after all seems lost. While this one didn’t include such a scene, the reveal of whodunnit at the end was expertly crafted and as fulfilling as I’d hoped for.

Dick Tracy - The Secret Files by Max Allan Collins & Martin H. Greenberg (ed)

In 1990, the film “Dick Tracy” was released. It starred Warren Beatty, Al Pacino, Dustin Hoffman, Madonna, and a bunch of other big-name stars. I have no evidence to support this, but it seems likely that this anthology, also published in 1990, was commissioned as a way to help market the film. Regardless, the choice of Max Allan Collins to edit the collection, along with prolific anthologist Martin H. Greenberg, could not have been a better one. Collins had taken over the writing of the Dick Tracy comic strip in 1977 when Chester Gould retired and had been at it for the 13 years prior to this book’s appearance. As a life-long fan of Dick Tracy, there can’t be many humans out there with a better understanding of what makes the world of Dick Tracy what it is.

Rarely have I read an anthology that I have enjoyed more than this one. Usually, they include some fine stories, some mediocre, and some best left on the cutting room floor. Not so with this one. I can honestly say I thoroughly enjoyed all but one of the stories included here and that one is by an author that is often troublesome for me anyway. But even then, it wasn’t “bad”. Hats off to Max Allan Collins and Martin Greenberg for their selections. The order in which the stories are presented is also well thought out. The very first story is entitled, “Origins” and written by Mike Resnick. It’s actually told from the point of view of a young, struggling writer named Chester Gould who meets a real-life detective who ultimately becomes a model for his new idea for a comic strip.

From there we have stories from the early Dick Tracy years in the 30s and 40s but also including more contemporary versions in a more modern age. We get to revisit villains from the strips such as Mumbles, Blowtop, B.O. Plenty, Gravel Gerty, Vitamin Flintheart, and Putty Puss but also read about brand new villains created just for this anthology. Some are written from some POV character other than Tracy himself. In addition to the aforementioned opening story featuring Chester Gould there is also one from the viewpoint of his wife, Tess Trueheart Tracy, and one from son "Junior".

The authors here are a real who’s who of speculative fiction and include Ed Gorman, F. Paul Wilson, Wayne D. Dundee, Barry N. Malzberg, Ric Myers, Stephen Mertz, Edward D. Hoch, Rex Miller, Mike Resnick, Ron Goulart, Barbara Collins, Henry Slesar, John Lutz, Terry Beatty, Wendi Lee, Francis M. Nevins Jr., Josh Pachter, and Max Allan Collins himself.

For fans of the original Dick Tracy comic strips or for those new to the character and just want a flavor for what it was all about, this collection is an ideal read. Highly recommended.

I'll Kill You Next! by Adam Knight (Lawrence Lariar)

Steve Conacher is a private investigator. He’s been hired by Luke Yorke, an aging cartoonist and well known as the man behind the famous “Caleb Straight” comic strip. Yorke has hired Conacher to locate Mike Smith, an up-and-coming cartoonist and Yorke’s protégé. Conacher is a good choice given his own friendship with Smith. But Conacher knows there is more to the story than just a missing persons case. Yorke is getting old, and he's ill. He needs somebody to take over the reigns of the comic strip and thinks Mike Smith has the talent to do so. Of greater concern to Conacher, however, is that Yorke’s spoiled brat of a nephew will take over unless Smith can be found.

The stakes grow higher when Mike Smith is found dead. It looks to be suicide, but Conacher knows better. The discovery of a new rival comic strip being readied for launch gives a prime motive for Smith to be cleared out of the way. But who is behind this new strip? Who has the talent? It seems likely that it’s one of three dames orbiting Luke Yorke’s world.

The author of this novel is Lawrence Lariar, writing under the pen name “Adam Knight”. He also wrote crime novels under the names Michael Stark and Marston la France. Lariar, however, was not only a novelist. He is perhaps better known in the world of comics where he worked as a cartoonist, a cartoon editor and as the compiler of the “Best Cartoons of the Year” series. He definitely knew the mid-20th century carton business and this novel reflects that expertise. At one point he couldn't resist having his main character, PI Conacher find a copy of “Best Cartoons of the Year” while searching a room.

So it seems the world of 1950s cartooning can be just as cut-throat as any other business, especially when three beautiful women are involved, each with their own agenda. Conacher gets beat up quite a lot over the course of the story, walking into ambushes, being clobbered over the head and waking up on some couch somewhere. But in the end, he proves his cerebral acuity, figuring out what’s been happening, and resolving the crime.

I should also mention the teaser quote on the back of the book: "She got what she wanted. She was an eye-catching dish with a low, throaty voice, and she purred like a caged tiger. As she slowly rose from the couch, she pointed the gun right at my stomach and whispered, “I got rid of him and now…I’ll Kill You Next!” Like many similar paperbacks of the 1950s, this quote and the title itself have little to do with the story. It’s pure marketing designed to get their readers (young men) to plunk down a quarter and buy the book. No such quote, or scene, appears in the novel.

While this wasn’t a remarkable reading experience for me, it was entertaining and kept me interested to see what happened next. Given the opportunity, I would read more of Lawrence Lariar’s crime fiction…and maybe check out his work in the comic industry as well.

Back Bay (Peter Fallon #1) by William Martin

I had read three or four stand-alone books by William Martin and enjoyed them all so I thought it was high time I began reading his Peter Fallon series.  Back Bay is actually the first novel he published, more than 30 years ago.  And, as expected, I enjoyed it very much.

This is a complex story that weaves historical events with a contemporary thriller/mystery-type plot.  Peter Fallon is a present-day student/historian working on his PhD and becomes entangled in a 200-year-old mystery concerning a silver tea set crafted by Paul Revere.  What follows is a multi-generational treasure hunt that drives the other aspects of the plot. I love the way the historical parts of the story are woven in among the contemporary scenes, allowing us to follow the history of the tea set and its impact on one very important and prominent New England family, the Pratts.  Chapters are presented alternately, with a historical chapter taking place in, say 1789, followed by a contemporary one.  I've read novels written this way before and sometimes they can be disruptive or downright confusing.  But not so with this one. There are a lot of plot threads here that have to connect across time and Martin does a fantastic job of keeping them all straight and allowing us readers to follow along easily, building suspense and intrigue along the way.

I also have to mention the setting.  Boston, especially historical Boston has long been a favorite of mine, ever since I read "Johnny Tremain" back in the 7th grade.  So along with the history of the Pratt family and the tea set, we get to witness the town of Boston grow through its history.  I've found the biggest theme in all of Martin's books is that we are the products of history and of our own personal decisions; the seemingly insignificant choice of some ancestor who made one small decision and thereby changed the lives of generations yet unborn, and of course, of the grand movements of history that affect us all.

Murder in Absentia (Felix the Fox #1) by Assaph Mehr

It's always fun to discover an intriguing concept for a novel and then see it executed so well. Here is a novel that combines a fantasy setting based on ancient Rome with a murder mystery. 

Felix is a professional investigator, an expert at retrieving information and putting together clues to solve crimes. A Roman PI, if you will. But he’s more than that because in this world of dark magic, he must understand those arts as well. When a young man is found dead, with a horrid, twisted look on his face, it is clear such dark forces have had their way with him. The dead man’s father happens to be a senator who suspects foul play so Felix is called on to the case.

The author of this book, Assaph Mehr, has done a remarkable job here. The world building alone is worth the price of admission. His descriptions of the Roman-like cities, structures, people, etc. are superb and provide a genuine flavor of what could be a real place. There are numerous “Roman” words used like Canicula, Gladius, Triclinium, and Pharos. Some are straight out of the actual language and some are fictional terms made up for this novel. There is a handy glossary included but frankly, I never felt the need to use it because the context was sufficient to understand the meanings. 

The magic system is entirely practical. It is also subtle, always there in the background but never hammering us with massive magical battles or detailed spell weaving. It blends in with the overall story very well, not stealing the thunder from the actual story of solving a murder. In fact, while this book is classified as a "fantasy", it reads more like historical mystery. As for solving the crime, that is also blended in well with the colorful cultural depictions and personalities we meet along the way. The solution is certainly not obvious and I had to wait until the final denouement when Felix gathers all the relevant parties ala Hercule Poirot to disclose the solution.

A fun novel all the way around, smartly written and begging for a sequel.  Thankfully, there is one, and hopefully more on the way.

Death Trap by John D. MacDonald

Hugh MacReedy has just returned to the US from Europe where he has spent two and a half years working on the construction of some military airfields. He’s ready to take a nice two-month vacation when he happens across a newspaper article describing the upcoming execution of the brother of an old girlfriend. Seems the man has been convicted of the rape and murder of a young woman, a local promiscuous tease of a girl. Hugh goes back to the small town where it all took place, gets back together with his old girlfriend, and begins investigating the circumstances of the crime.

This novel was MacDonald's nineteenth novel, first published in February 1957. The plot is a fairly straight-forward murder investigation by a non-professional. Hugh is a construction engineer, not a private investigator. But he is an intelligent fellow and is very good at pounding the pavement, speaking with those involved, and putting together the subtle clues to solve the mystery and determine the real rapist/murderer. In fact, he identifies the culprit pretty early, about half-way through the book, and the story changes from a sleuthing mystery to more of a thriller. Hugh, working now with several other townspeople, must find actual evidence in order to grant a stay of execution for the wrongfully convicted brother of his girlfriend and bring the real killer to justice.

This novel was written in the early prime of MacDonald’s writing career. Before the Travis McGee novels, which largely took over his writing life, his stand-alones showed a genuine progression as he matured as a writer and this one clearly shows his prowess with the written word. The main character, Hugh MacReady is a typical MacDonald protagonist. He is tall, strong, tanned, and women find him attractive. He is a professional man doing man's work. But he is also different in that he committed a major blunder in his early days, having wooed, bedded, and then abandoned his girlfriend. She was nothing more than another notch in his belt. Thus, after returning to that same small town after three years, his rekindling of that relationship, genuine this time, represents a correction of his moral flaw. This moral theme is seen often in MacDonald’s prose.

For those readers who tend to read only John D. MacDonald's Travis McGee books, I recommend pursuing his other novels as well. For the most part, they are real treats. As this one is.

Wobble to Death by Peter Lovesey

A “wobble’, for the uninitiated, is a pedestrian contest wherein competitors walk or run for a set period of time, trying to complete as much distance as possible before time is called. It eventually transformed into the modern sport of speed walking. Just such a wobble is the setting for this whodunnit novel set in London, 1879 and the set time is 6 days. That’s a long walk by anyone’s standards but when one of the primary competitors is found dead by strychnine poisoning, Sgt Cribb and his constable partner, Thackeray are called in to investigate.

This first book in the eight volume Sgt Cribb series is the very first book ever published by the highly regarded Peter Lovesey. I’ve been wanting to sample some of his work ever since I saw him as a panelist at a conference. A witty, charming, and downright hilarious speaker, he has won just about every mystery author award in existence. This book shows plenty of signs of that award winning style and it is difficult to believe this is a first effort written more than 45 years ago. I will say that it got off to a bit of a slow start (no racing pun intended) with the body not being discovered until nearly 20% of the way through. Up to that point it was all about the racers themselves and I was starting to think this was a sports novel rather than a murder mystery. But once Sgt Cribb arrives on the scene, it’s filled with all the clues, red herrings, and final denouement that one expects from such a story. There is also a very subtle humor running throughout the book, more due to the nature of the setting than actual events.

The mystery was good and I will admit to having to wait for Sgt Cribb to ID the murderer for me but in hindsight I could see it clearly. That’s a sign of a solid mystery for me. I do feel that I will need another book or two to really get to know Cribb but Thackeray seemed a bit more fleshed out. Happily, this isn’t a series where the main sleuth is a genius and the sidekick a bumbler who serves as a foil for the reader. Rather, both men are capable investigators and work well together while neither is a perfect detective.

Looking forward to sampling more of this series as well as some of Lovesey’s other works.