West of Dodge - A Western Anthology from Saddlebag Dispatches Magazine

Full Disclosure: I have a story ("Vigilance Committee") published in this volume. My review is based on the entire anthology, taken as a whole.

Saddlebag Dispatches has been publishing western-themed magazines since 2014 and has racked up numerous accolades for the quality of their content, both fiction and non-fiction. For many, it has become the go-to source for up-to-date information on all things western. Happily, they've decided to expand their frontiers by publishing a series of western fiction short-story anthologies. This very first one, published this summer of 2023, features the theme of Dodge City, coinciding with the Summer 2023 edition of the magazine. Future themed anthologies are planned for every six months.

West of Dodge contains short stories from 20 contemporary authors, ranging from vastly experienced writers such as Dusty Richards and Velda Brotherton to the neophyte author. Having read them all, I can honestly say that it's difficult to tell which ones are which.

As expected, several stories take place in Dodge City itself, featuring different time periods in that town's turbulent history. Often, we come across historical characters from Wyatt Earp to Charlie Bassett but more often the stories are about regular folks faced with difficult, if not insurmountable circumstances. Many of the stories do not, however take place in Dodge City but rather roam across the West, fulfilling the title's promise, "West of Dodge". These 20 stories provide a full range of styles, but I can honestly say I enjoyed every one of them. As I do for most anthologies, I chose to read one of these stories between each novel, letting them act as a sort of pallet cleanser. That also keeps these stories fresh for me.

It's great to see new Western-themed anthologies being published once again. This one certainly deserves your further attention.

Rattler's Law - Volume Two by James Reasoner

A couple of years ago I was introduced to a volume of eight western novels featuring the character of Lucas Flint, newly arrived marshal of Abilene Kansas, and known as “The Rattler” for his lightning-fast draw. Those eight books proved to be a rich tapestry of interrelated yarns encompassing an entire cast of towns people including deputies, saloon owners, church leaders, schoolteachers, a female doctor, and assorted others. Much like a long-running television series of yesteryear, new arrivals populate each story, like guest stars if you will. Some are hard-working honest folks looking for a better life while others are seeking fortune of a different kind and don’t care about how they get it. Those eight books were wonderful reads and taken together formed a real saga of western life during those times.

I knew there was a second volume to be had, another eight novels that carried on that saga and it has been at the top of my TBR list ever since. This year, I tackled it, choosing to read one story every month or thereabouts in order to stretch out the experience. Alas, today, I find myself in early September, and have just turned the page on the final story. It’s bittersweet to be honest. These stories are every bit as good as the first volume and maybe even a little more interconnected. It was a true joy to revisit the characters and see them respond to new threats and opportunities. But, at least as of this writing, there are no more.

This volume sees the rise of a dastardly villain, Jason Kent, whose far-reaching plots are the stuff of real conflict. His villainy lasts through many of these stories, and one begins to wonder if he’ll ever meet his match. Author James Reasoner writes multi-dimensional characters even if that means showing vulnerabilities and, in this series, Lucas Flint doesn’t always come out on top. Many of the stories see other characters take center stage and ultimately are the ones to see justice served although Flint’s guiding hand is always present. But in the end, it is the ensemble cast that makes these books work so well.

Those readers looking for an “adult” western need to look elsewhere but those wanting a good story with well-drawn characters, traditional western style, plenty of action, and interesting plots need look no further.

I hope for more of these books someday but will not hold my breath. With sixteen books available over two collections, I can easily go back and dip into them now and again and relish the experience of this delightful series once again. Highly recommended.

Glorious (Cash McLendon #1) by Jeff Guinn

I’ve been a fan of Jeff Guinn’s non-fiction work ever since I read Go Down Together: The True, Untold Story of Bonnie and Clyde, his informative and exceedingly readable account of the Barrow Gang. When I saw he had written a couple of western fiction tales I wanted to try them so now I have.

If this first one is a true indicator of the rest of the series, I can emphatically say, I will be reading every book in the series, and any other fiction he decides to produce in the future. Jeff Guinn is a knowledgeable guy, a researcher extraordinaire with the nonfiction credits to prove it. It certainly shows up in his fiction as well. While the town of Glorious, Arizona is fictional it bears all the markings of a wannabe silver mining bonanza town. They haven’t struck silver yet, but the handful of town founders have put everything in their hopes and dreams.

The plot features Cash McLendon, a man on the run who makes the journey from St. Louis to Glorious, AZ Territory in 1872, chasing after a girl, a lost love. We’re not sure what he is running from in the opening pages, but we do get a nice flashback sequence later on that thoroughly grounds him in our hearts and minds. When he arrives in Glorious, he meets an oddball bunch of characters, and it is clear he doesn’t belong there. A true fish out of water, Cash has never held a gun or ridden a horse, but he does have that sense of stick-to-itiveness that is characteristic of the people of the West. As the novel unfolds, Cash, as well as us readers, come to love these townspeople and all their foibles. So, when the danger comes in the form of a prosperous power-hungry rancher intent on becoming lord of the territory and all its potential silver deposits, we genuinely fear for the townspeople’s futures.

I really enjoyed this one. Unlike many of today’s readers, I read a lot of westerns and have experienced the entire range of the genre, from literary masterpieces like Lonesome Dove to the adult westerns like "Longarm" and "Edge", to the latest potboiler yarn by the current house name authors. This one falls somewhere in between. It has some action but leans more toward the slow build-up of suspense rather than full-on six-shooter action. The real draw is the charm of the town of Glorious and its realistic, if sometimes quirky, characters. Actual historical characters make an appearance too, most notably Ike Clanton who plays a major role. Cash McLendon is a wonderful character, a man who learns to know what it is that he really wants from life, working toward it, making mistakes along the way, and still finding ways to take the nobler path even when it conflicts with his own goals.

The end of the novel leaves Cash and everybody else in a precarious situation so I need to procure book two pronto. Greatly looking forward to reading it and the rest of the series.

The Tin Lizzie Troop by Glendon Swarthout

During the Mexican-American border campaign of 1916 during which 100,000 national guardsmen were called up to defend the US against raiding Mexican bandits, an incident took place that resulted in the first ever mechanized infantry engagement. This novel, by American writer Glendon Swarthout, takes a humorous (and fictionalized) view of that event, resulting in a fun read indeed.

General Blackjack Pershing’s fruitless chase of Pancho Villa took all the headlines at the time but here we follow Lt. Stanley Dinkle, commander of Patrol Post No. 2 based out of Ft. Bliss. A rotation of National Guardsman perform a tour of duty for a month at a time under his command and this time it is six members of the Philadelphia Light Horse. Officially they are national guard but in reality they are the sons of wealthy hoity-toity military men’s club members. Naturally, they expect their tour of duty to be nothing but fun and games. Among their gear are polo mallets, a Victrola phonograph, and two Ford Model T automobiles.

When Lt Dinkle is granted leave in El Paso for a weekend, he leaves one of the six men in charge and of course everything goes to Hell. They are raided by Mexican bandits, their horses stolen, and a local homely maiden is kidnapped. The very honor of the Philadelphia Light Horse is at stake! Against all orders, they cross the Rio Grande and charge toward the bandits. However, they soon learn that Model T’s racing across the desert tend to encounter all sorts of mechanical problems that horses do not.

This is the funniest novel I have read in a long time. Nearly every line, whether dialog or not is humorous in one way or another. It combines farcical situations with some surprising pathos. And it also contains some shockingly violent scenes. It’s like reading a Monty Python skit as directed by Quentin Tarantino. A movie version was almost made staring Paul Newman. Too bad it wasn’t. I would have paid to see that.

War in Sandoval County by Wayne D. Overholser

I’ve been wanting to read a Wayne D. Overholser western ever since I saw him referenced in Stephen King's novel Wolves of the Calla, part of King's "Dark Tower" saga.  Overholser was among the earlier group of American western writers and, in fact, won the very first Spur Award in 1953 for his novel, Law Man. Like many others of his time, Wayne cut his teeth in the pulps, his first story published in 1936.

In this book, Jeff Ardell is a man caught in the middle of a range war. He begins the book as part of the “Big 4” ranchers in the high prairie region near Starbuck, Colorado.  An ugly cattle-rustling problem causes the leader of the Big 4, Ben Shortt, to call in a “livestock detective” to find proof of the re-branding activity. However, the man he secretly calls in, Sam Marks, is a notorious killer, known for his cowardly way of shooting unsuspecting men in the back. Jeff sees Shortt’s power-grab for what it is and decides to pull out of the Big 4. But trying to determine who his friends are and who might be selling him out to the killer is only part of his problem now.

This book has plenty of gun-slinging action and back-stabbing twists as Jeff stubbornly takes on the existing power structure. It’s not just about how Jeff can outmaneuver his foes but how can he lead his side against so many people arrayed against him. Even the good guys tend toward the gray side of the scale, so Jeff has some moral dilemmas to wade through.

An enjoyable read with a satisfying ending that makes me want to hunt down some more of Overholser’s work.

King of the Mountain (Wilderness #1) by David Thompson (David Robbins)

In the year 1828, 19-year-old Nathaniel King is slaving away at an accountant’s job in New York City, struggling to earn enough to keep his fiancée happy and living the kind of luxurious life to which she has grown accustomed. Afraid he will never earn enough to please her, he jumps at a chance to gain a vast treasure. Seems his Uncle Ezekiel (Zeke), a man who moved to the great unexplored West some ten years previously had found this treasure and now wants Nate to have it. Nate travels to St. Louis, meets his uncle and together they make the adventurous trek to the cabin in the Rocky Mountains where the treasure awaits.

I’ve long wanted to begin this series of western/frontier novels. The prolific David Robbins, writing under the name David Thompson did not disappoint. He packs this novel with one adventure after another, from a thief ambush in a dark alley, to a ferocious grizzly bear attack, to several hair-raising (pun-intended) encounters with various Indian tribes. Along their journey, Nate and his uncle share experiences and Nate learns as much as he can, learning of the beauty of his surroundings as well as the violent kill-or-be-killed nature of life in the wild.

The novel works very well as an origin story of Nate King, an unlikely Mountain man but a true hero of frontier fiction. The end of this novel sets up the next and it's easy to see this lends itself to a lengthy series. Robbins does add some social commentary at regular intervals, especially in pointing out the characteristics and foibles of civilized life in the Eastern US appearing less attractive and less honest than what is experienced by the hard-working frontiersman. The novel is easy reading and harkens back to the pulp style of ending each chapter in a cliffhanger.

A fun read to be sure. I now have yet another long series to pursue but that is the sort of problem I like to have.

Shoot-Out at Sugar Creek (Caleb York #6) by Mickey Spillane and Max Allan Collins

This sixth book in the Caleb York series directly follows the events of book #5, Hot Lead, Cold Justice, in which a killer blizzard swept across the Southwest putting lives and whole ranches in peril. Trying to recover from that experience has proven no easy task. Wealthy widow and cattle baroness, Victoria Drummond, has seized the opportunity to snatch up most of the smaller ranches in the area of Trinidad, New Mexico, and now has her sites set on the vast Bar-O spread, owned and managed by Willa Cullen, the getting-close-to-fiancé-status girlfriend of one Sheriff Caleb York.

There is no level to which Victoria will not stoop to get what she wants, to include hiring an army of hard case gunfighters from nearby Las Vegas, setting up ambushes, and even sacrificing her own sons to the effort. She has the upper hand against the Bar-O due to controlling Sugar Creek, the only water supply that’s not fouled by dead cattle from the massive blizzard. So, when Sheriff York is forced to shoot and kill Victoria’s son for raping and beating a saloon trollop, a full-on range war is ignited.

Some readers expect the character of Caleb York to be simply a western version of Mike Hammer but I find Caleb to be a much more sympathetic character. He is loyal to the law and to maintaining the peace, but he is a firm stand-your-ground kind of man and never backs down from a fight. He’s an excellent shot, of course, and always manages to find plenty of action to test his skills, but he would prefer that was not the case.

The plot of this novel tests not only Caleb York’s skills with a gun but also his hot-cold-warm-hot relationship with Willa Cullen, once again. The stakes have never been higher, and the body-count is stratospheric. With the title of this novel being what it is, a lot of gunplay is expected but man-o-man was that spectacular! I was fully invested in these characters after the very first book in the series, The Legend of Caleb York, and the rest of the series has only increased that for me. So, when one of them gets such a raw deal as we see here, I’m all in for revenge in the purest sense of the word.

I really hope there are more Caleb York novels still to come. Please let it be so.

Hardcase by Luke Short

Dave Coyle is an outlaw. The sort of outlaw that thumbs his nose at the law, that can escape any jail he’s thrown in, and generally is able to strut about with confidence that his skills are superior to anybody who might disagree with him. But he is loyal to his friends and his actions are mostly honorable. So, when pretty Carol McFee asks for his help in saving her father from having his ranch suckered out from under him with a fake bill-of-sale, Coyle steps in to assist.

I’ve read several hundred westerns over the years, but this is my first by Luke Short, pen name of Frederick Dilley Glidden and not to be confused with the gunfighter of the Old West. Most of his work was published in the 1930s and 40s. This book was first published in 1941 and definitely has that pulp western vibe to it.

The novel is certainly a western novel, but it has many hallmarks of other genres, especially hard-boiled crime with a strong mystery element. Dave Coyle is the protagonist but not afraid to act outside the law to right a wrong. He’s hard-headed but smart. The novel certainly is titled appropriately. The plot is a complex whirlwind of interesting characters. With a couple of exceptions, the reader isn’t always sure who are the good guys and who are the bad hombres. The very nature of the power structure in the town, including the sheriff and his deputy, is well thought out and provided a lot of intrigue, double-crosses, and the mandatory fight scenes. I was impressed with the nature of the scheme to steal the ranch. Very creative, as was the solution engineered by Dave Coyle. The ending was great fun as Coyle proves his own innocence and nails the bad guy in an unorthodox Old West court of law. It’s not a flawless novel to be sure with some parts that wandered around a little, but ultimately it pulled me right along.

I’m glad I read this one and will be looking for more westerns by Luke Short.

Easy Company and the Medicine Gun (Easy Company #2) by John Wesley Howard (Stephen Winston)

Stephen Winston takes over the reins from Lou Cameron to pen this second book in the 31-book Easy Company series. He would go on to write at least five more.

Less than a year after the events of Little Bighorn, Easy Company continues its mission of maintaining a shaky peace in the region. They are receiving new recruits due to some recent attrition and this novel’s plot centers around those characters although the regulars also get in on some good action.  I get the feeling there might be a lot of new recruits necessary for this company of mounted infantry, (don’t dare call them cavalry) based on the body count in this outing alone.

A Gatling gun (known as a medicine gun to the Indians because of its ability to deal out rapid “big medicine”) has been stolen before it can complete its journey to a reservation in the North. The crew has been slaughtered and it appears the notorious Racing Elk and his band are responsible. As new clues come to light, different groups of Easy Company, including the new recruits hit the trail in pursuit, each experiencing their own separate types of adventure.

I’m not sure if it’s because of a different author from book one or if it’s due to the demands of the publisher but this entry kicks up the adult content a notch or two. Some of it is quite imaginative. But the other parts are equally imaginative, including the gunfights, camp politics, and the new characters’ backgrounds. It all makes for another solid entry in the series. Book three is written by Kenneth Bjorgum, another author in the stable behind the “John Wesley Howard” pseudonym. I’m curious to see what his style will bring to these characters.

Wyoming Wanton (Gunn #16) by Jory Sherman

William “Gunn” Gunnison Is resting up in Denver after a particularly intense experience (see the previous book in the series, “Drygultched”). He’s asked to meet somebody, a stranger, after dark in an alley. Turns out to be a message from an old friend up in Cheyenne who has been accused of murder, and needs Gunn to come and testify at his trial. But opposing forces are determined to keep that from happening and set about trying to kill Gunn before he can arrive in Wyoming. Worse, they are killing other men and using Gunn’s special mark on them as a way to set him up for the murders.

This is the 16th book in the “Gunn” series, but the first one I’ve ever tried. Frankly, I wasn’t expecting much from it based on the cover, suspecting it to be just another 2-bit Slocum-style knock-off. I had picked it up in one of those Friends of the Library sales where you get a full grocery bag of books for $5. 

But…I was pleasantly surprised. No, this type of novel will never win a Spur award from the Western Writers of America, but it was a pretty good, entertaining read. It is of the "adult western" variety with the obligatory 3 sex scenes per book but those can be easily skipped over if the reader isn't interested. Plenty of action occurs, but there is some pretty nice character development as well, and a healthy dose of mystery and intrigue. The end includes a fun courtroom scene which rings true for a circuit-riding judge who is more interested in swift justice than accurate justice.

While I had never heard of author Jory Sherman before, this book intrigued me enough to look him up, only to discover he is, in fact, the author of over 400 books, many of them set in the American West, as well as poetry, articles, and essays. His best-known works may be the Spur Award-winning The Medicine Horn, first in the “Buckskinner” series, and Grass Kingdom, part of the “Barons of Texas” series. He also contributed four books to the Ralph Compton "Trail Drive" series. Sherman won the Owen Wister Award for Lifetime Contributions to Western Literature from the Western Writers of America. Pretty impressive.

One interesting side note. The author includes a character in this book, a deputy sheriff named “Bob Randisi”. Of course, Robert J Randisi, under the pseudonym “J.R. Roberts”, is the author of all 477 of “The Gunsmith” novels (and counting), along with numerous other books in the western, crime/mystery genres as well as numerous anthologies. I'm betting they knew each other, and Sherman was just having a little fun here.

Based on this book, I will be looking for more from Jory Sherman, whether in this “Gunn” series or from his other works.

The Hellbenders Trilogy by Richard Prosch

The American Civil War is drawing closer to a reality, but the Mexican/American War is still on the minds of many in the Southwest. Cortina’s Mexican insurgents have just laid waste to a large chunk along the Rio Grande and now a Tejano named Cardoza has his sights set on taking over a ranch, with dreams of many more such targets to come. However, at the behest of his uncle, Texas Ranger Lin Jarret rides into the middle of this war, with the primary mission of watching out for Reece Sinclair, daughter of ranch owner Tom Sinclair, heiress to the large spread.

While he expects a spoiled rich girl, Reece turns out to be far more than he bargained for, fully capable of protecting herself and the ranch, all while leading a secret mission all her own. As an abolitionist, she finds a like-minded soul in Lin Jarret. Together they become “Hellbenders”.

Author Richard Prosch is an experienced wordsmith, and his storytelling prowess is on full display here in these three novels. While there is plenty of gunplay and action scenes to please those that thrive on such plots, this book is far more than that. I’ve read many a western novel in my time and rarely do I get to enjoy the characters of a novel as much as I do here. They really leap off the page, fully realized, complete with realistic personalities and motivations. They’re the type that could absolutely be real people. Even the minor characters (and there are quite a few), felt real to me. The author’s ability to capture the lingo and the sounds of the various cultures in the novel is truly impressive.

In the second novel, “Seven Devils Road”, we see that the Order of the Ivory Compass is working hard to establish their ideal of a new country carved out of parts of the American South, West, and Caribbean wherein slavery shall remain an institution forever. Now, they have their sights set on Missouri. In order to help finance their version of the Underground Railroad, the Hellbenders recruit a few compadres and proceed with a scheme to rob a train of assets owned by the Ivory Compass themselves. What better way to build a resistance than to use your opponent's wealth? The bad guys soon get wind of the robbery, leading to a perilous chase along the Butterfield Overland Trail in a coach as it makes its way from Syracuse to Fort Smith, Arkansas.

This second book is just as full of gritty action and perilous situations as the first. The main characters retain their intriguing personalities while new ones provide plenty of new charisma and drama. Of course, Richard Prosch continues to demonstrate his ability to capture the voices of his characters. Mixed in with the fire-spitting gunfights and threats coming from all corners, is a nice mix of relationships and humor. Additionally, there is some interesting history sprinkled in. For example, I’d never heard of the Walch Navy 12-shot revolver. It’s a .36 caliber revolver patented in 1859 utilizing superimposed chambers, which means that each of the six chambers could hold two shots, for a total of 12 rounds before reloading. It had two hammers and two side by side triggers, with the trigger for the front loading being positioned slightly ahead of the rear load’s trigger, to help ensure that they are fired in the correct order. Pretty cool gun and when used in the novel, provides for a unique gunfight.

The third novel, “A Killing at Rimrock”, opens with Texas Ranger Lin Jarret and his pretty partner Reece Sinclair using their stagecoach to transport a passenger named Dale Hemlock to an important Cotton Growers Association meeting. Cotton is the foundation of the economy in Texas in 1860 so the Cotton Growers are extremely important. It also seems inevitable that there will be war between the states.

Local disputes involving the transportation of alcohol across the Red River fuel an already volatile situation that also involves the conflict between the abolitionists and the Order of the Ivory Compass. Caught in the middle are our Hellbenders, whose reputation for leading escaped slaves to safety is growing.

All three Hellbender novels tie together but they can also each be read and enjoyed separately. His two primary protagonists, Lin Jarret and Reece Sinclair make for an ideal pair to carry the plot. To quote from the book, “He was flour, she was water. Together they were hard tack – able to see through the rough times and last damn near forever.” The other characters are all well-drawn and serve well to enhance the realistic setting and atmosphere as well as advancing the plot at the same time. And believe me there is lots of action here including gunplay, fist and knife fights, stagecoach peril, as well as some intriguing mental one-upmanship. It's especially gratifying to see Reece hold her own in these conflicts.

I genuinely hope this is not the final novel in the Hellbenders series. It would be interesting to see how Lin and Reece carry on with their Hellbenders mission once the war begins in earnest.

Highly recommended. 

Town Tamers by David Robbins

David Robbins is one of the most prolific authors anywhere, having created and authored hundreds of novels under at least seven different pseudonyms, in a variety of genres. These include dozens of entries in both the ‘Endworld’ and ‘Blade’ post-apocalyptic series, 'The Executioner' series, and many stand-alone novels. The western genre has also been blessed with his output with over 70 books in the ‘Wilderness’ series under his David Thompson pseudonym, a handful of books under the Ralph Compton brand, as well as numerous contributions to 'The Trailsman’ series, writing as Jon Sharpe. 

This novel opens with Asa Delaware, well-known town tamer, about to take on his latest project.  Ludlow, Texas is being run by a group of rowdy and violent cowhands, but the town has hired Asa and his sawed-off shotgun to “resolve” the problem. Together with his son, a poetry loving strategic thinker, and his daughter, a danger-loving crack-shot, they rapidly fix the problem, leaving no baddie alive. There is enough action and well-written gun play here to satisfactorily fill most standard western novels, but all this comprises only the first third of the book.

The bulk of the novel is taken with the trio’s operations in the fictional town of Ordville, Colorado, having been hired by a victim instead of the town council. This is a different situation than they’ve faced before. No violent power-wielding thugs or shoot-outs in the streets here, but rather a peaceful, and amazingly prosperous town that the citizens love. Digging deeper though, Asa discovers a hidden puppet master who controls the town’s wealth, the local law, and has anybody who gets in his way brutally beaten or killed. Worse, the three town tamers have no protection from authorities to cover for their typically lethal methods. What unfolds is a masterful display of strategy, cunning, and unfolding tension.

Asa Delaware is a fascinating character and the author does an excellent job of balancing the bits and pieces of his backstory and characterization with edge-of-your-seat action. Robbins displays a talent for making a wildly over-the-top adventure seem perfectly logical and for keeping the reader completely engaged from the first chapter through the last. It’s no surprise that this book, rests easily in the high-quality pantheon of David Robbin’s portfolio.

The Killers of Cimarron by Frank Leslie (Peter Brandvold)

Nothing in life had turned out right for him so far.  Being dead couldn’t really be all that bad.

The second novel in the Colter Farrow series picks up with Colter attempting to make a new life as a ranch hand in the Cheyenne Mountains of Wyoming.  He’s on the run from bounty hunters but hopes the word has not reached this far north. Difficult to do considering his face is prominently branded from a horrendous feud with a corrupt sheriff in his past. Now he works for Cimarron Padilla. It's hard but honest work, and it also has its perks, including Cimarron’s beautiful adopted Hunkpapa daughter, Pearl.  Of course, life can’t stay that ideal for long and indeed, a band of ornery killers who have previously robbed a cache of Army gold, invade Colter’s new idyllic life followed but a whole lot of double-fisted pot boiler action.  

Frank Leslie is a pseudonym of the always reliable Peter Brandvold.  He's probably best known for his other western series characters such as Yakima Henry, Lou Prophet, Sheriff Ben Stillman, and others but I'm here to tell you not to skip over this Colter Farrow series. I’ve read a lot of westerns over the years, including Louis L'Amour-style traditional westerns, adult westerns like Longarm, and Slocum, and those from the Piccadilly Cowboys like Edge, Crow, and Gringos.  This series is almost a combination of all of them, filled with some traditional themes but told in a modern syle, and a bit rougher around the edges.  It’s definitely violent and has some titillating sexual innuendo, though not blatant. And as with most Brandvold westerns, you have no guarantee of a happily ever-after ending.  The prose is excellent with some descriptive passages almost poetic in nature. It was exactly the type of western I was looking for when I picked it up: a great story filled with edge-of-your-seat suspense, action, intrigue, and even some wry humor.

I enjoyed the main character of Colter a lot but I have to say the other main character, Spurr Logan, really stole the show in this volume.  He’s an old deputy federal marshal out of Denver, one that should probably have retired several years ago.  His “ticker” is on borrowed time, but his libido and cantankerous attitude are both full speed ahead.  

While this is the second book in the series, I found that reading it as a stand-alone is perfectly fine.  Previous events are referred to a little bit but not much.  It does however create a great need on my part to read the remaining books in the series! 

Bendigo Shafter by Louis L'Amour

A small group of westward-bound pioneers, making their way to what they hope will be a better life, find themselves running out of time. It’s too close to winter to make it over the mountains so they decide to stop and build a small town of sorts, just some place to survive until the warmer weather of spring would arrive once again. They were seven men and thirteen women and children, among them a young man of eighteen by the name of Bendigo Shafter.

Louis L’Amour, the best-selling western author of all time offers up one of his most beloved tales. This is not a traditional western novel crammed full of gunfights, cattle rustling, town taming and the like, although all those things do occur in this book. Rather, this is more of a historical fiction novel, a “frontier” story depicting the harsh conditions and challenges under which a community is carved out. Ben “Bendigo” Shafter is the ideal man to face the situations that arise, wise beyond his years but always seeking out new knowledge. In the midst of becoming a leader of the town, he wonders what his future holds, as well as what the future of the town may be.

I’ve read most of Louis L’Amour’s body of work and would rank this one in the top five. Given his prolific output, that’s really saying something. I always like a good frontier yarn filled with mountain men, rough characters, and the ever-present threat of an Indian uprising. I really enjoyed the character of Bendigo Shafter and his approach to life, especially his penchant for reading whatever books he could get his hands on in order to improve himself. Having read L’Amour’s autobiography, I know that is a trait shared by both author and character. Indeed, there is quite a bit of the author’s background that infuses Bendigo, including his extensive travels during his formative years. Yes, Bendigo is a bit too perfect to be true but he struggles now and then just like we all do. And besides, it's nice once in a while to read a novel where the good guy is just that - a good guy. Several other characters provide a well-balanced “family” for Bendigo, including a fellow by the name of Ethan Sackett. Putting a Sackett in a L’Amour novel is always a wise decision.  But in the end, it is the town itself that ties the events of the novel together. That feeling of building something with your own hands infuses the narrative, and to then see it grow and prosper is very fulfilling. Plenty of pitfalls occur, mistakes made, and obstacles overcome, all towards a brighter future.

This is L’Amour at his best. It’s a novel of hope, destiny, and an unerring sense that change is the only constant in our lives. 

Highly recommended.

Hot Lead - Most Wanted All Review Special by Justin Mariott

As part of the Hot Lead series of fanzines, Justin Marriott brings us an all-review special. It came out last year, in 2020 and was one of the few bright spots in an otherwise horrible year. It's a wonderful resource for fans of western fiction. More than 160 pages and over 200 reviews representing the vast history of the western paperback are all here for the taking. It is perhaps the best such resource of its kind in existence today.

The Forward to this volume, by noted comic book writer and western author Chuck Dixon sets the proper tone of enthusiasm for the genre as a whole.  Justin Marriott himself provides a thoughtful introduction while three more informative and addictive essays are also included: Paul Bishop examines ten of his favorite western authors, Howard Andrew Jones takes a deep dive into westerns in the Gold Medal line and Gary Dobbs provides a thorough analysis of Larry McMurtry’s Lonesome Dove Saga.   

The reviews themselves are organized chronologically with major divisions by “era” beginning in 1927 all the way to modern day westerns. You’ll find everything from stand-alone classics to western series, adult westerns, weird westerns, and even the comics. Each is granted a rating by the reviewer and of course, not all will agree, but there-in lies an extra bit of fun when reading them. I found more than a few that I at first disagreed with but the text of the review sells their rating and now has me thinking I might revisit them to see if my own opinion might change.

This is a fairly hefty product, especially considering the price. Most of the reviews are accompanied by black & white cover photos of the original publication and that in itself can be a fun way to browse.  One note of caution however: readers might well find themselves significantly expanding their wish lists for future reads so check your bank account before delving in.

** On a side note, I feel a little conflicted about reviewing this product at all since I have ten or so reviews in here myself. My words above reflect all the other content in the book, and I would feel the same even were I not included. Nevertheless, it was an honor and a privilege to contribute to the effort. **

Easy Company and the Suicide Boys by John Wesley Howard

On the high plains of Wyoming Territory in the 1870’s sits Outpost Number Nine. It’s home to the fictional “Easy Company”, a unit of mounted infantry (don’t call them cavalry) in the days after Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer lost at the Battle of Little Bighorn. Easy Company is charged with maintaining the fragile peace with the Indian tribes in the area but also stand ready to fight, should that action be called for.

This is the first novel in the Easy Company series of 31 westerns written by a number of authors using the John Wesley Howard pseudonym. This time (and apparently the only time), the author is Lou Cameron, the author who brought us 'Longarm' as well as the 'Renegade' series and the 'Stringer' series among many others. The “suicide boys” of the book’s title refer to a group of young, untested, would-be Indian warriors out to prove their bravery, and their actions in the novel lead to conflicts with the outpost.

I thoroughly enjoyed this first book in the series.  The main characters of Easy Company, including the commander, his officers, 1st Sergeant, and a handful of enlisted men are all introduced as the story unfolds, as are the various leaders of the Indian tribes. An additional source of conflict arrives in the form of an IG inspector, a by-the-book man who struggles to understand why Easy Company finds it necessary to interpret the regulations creatively from time to time in order to preserve the peace.

If this first book is an indication of the quality of the entire series…well, I only have 30 more to read and I’ll enjoy each one of them.

Men's Adventure Quarterly, Vol 1 by Bob Deis & Bill Cunningham

Color me impressed!

This is the first volume of what I sure hope is a continuing quarterly publication of stories and essays from the golden age of what are known as “MAMs” or Men’s Adventure Magazines. These were magazines mostly from the 1950s-60s that were geared toward men, often violent and with pulpy adventure style yarns. More often than not, the stories were accompanied by colorful art that featured scantily clad women. The publishers, after all, knew their target audience.

Now, Robert Deis and Bill Cunningham have put their considerable knowledge of the MAMs to work for our enjoyment. Each volume will focus on a single theme. This first one focuses on westerns and the second revolves around the world of espionage while the third devotes itself to the world of vigilantes. I own them all will be posting reviews of them as well, shortly.

This is a large, slick, high-quality product.  The cover alone makes my mouth water. But it is the contents that really blow me away. It’s chock full of reprinted stories and articles from the original MAMs as well as wonderful introductions by Bob Deis, Bill Cunningham, and guest editor, Paul Bishop. There are nine stories presented from the likes of “MALE”, “Man’s Life”, and “All Man” magazines complimented by impressive original full color and B&W artwork. It’s absolutely gorgeous. Additionally, there are a couple of in-depth articles as well as a full color art gallery of classic covers.

All of that would have added up to a sure-fire winner. But, for me, what really drives it over the top are the introductions to each story and article. Often when I read anthologies, I feel lucky when a story is introduced with a paragraph or two providing some background. But here, we get two and three pages of intro, describing each story’s origins, the author’s life, the artists involved and even the publishing background. The folks behind this publication really know their subject and their passion for all of it shines through in spades.

This will have a permanent place on my shelves, right alongside every issue that is published in the future. Highest recommendation!

Rattler's Law, Volume One by James Reasoner

Lucas Flint is the new marshal of Abilene, Kansas, an experienced lawman but a man that had no plans to resume his career, much less in the notoriously wild town of Abilene. After all, to fill the shoes of the last marshal, Wild Bill Hickock would be no easy task. But his moniker of “Rattler” describes his lightning-fast draw, as fast as a rattlesnake and that reputation serves him well when facing down the bad guys.

This volume compiles the first eight novels in the series and each one of them is a joy to read. These are traditional westerns. If they were movies, they would be rated PG. Flint makes for a fine protagonist as the first novel sees him tame the town and subsequent tales depict situations where he must maintain the peace. Whether it's a circus that's come to town or a fiery visitor from the Women's Temperance Society looking to banish all whiskey, you can be sure Flint will find himself in the middle of it and having to use his fast draw to solve the problem. But he’s far from alone in his efforts, supported by major characters such as his loyal but rough-around-the-edges deputy Cully Markham, and a Scottish saloon proprietor named Angus MacQuarrie who can wield a mean shotgun. Other characters include the female town doctor, the school master, and Cully’s brother Joshua who also happens to be the town pastor. 

Each story stands on its own but it’s a joy to return to the setting each time and revisit these characters. In some ways it reminds me of a television show like Gunsmoke, albeit with longer movie-length episodes. Prolific author James Reasoner has described these novels as rewritten and expanded versions of some of his early Western novels.

Wonderful stuff all the way through. Happily, I already own Volume 2, consisting of eight more novels. Can’t wait to get back to them.

Six-Gun Poker by Ron Goulart

Prolific author Ron Goulart has used many pen names over the years, including Kenneth Robeson (12 books in The Avenger series), Con Steffanson (Alex Raymond’s Flash Gordon books), and many others. In addition, he’s done a lot of comic book writing for such series as Vampirella and Phantom. He’s even the ghost author behind William Shatner’s “TekWar” series. But it was as “Zeke Masters” that he compiled a series of 31 western novels featuring the likable card shark and faro banker, “Faro Blake”.

This eleventh book in the series opens with Blake in the small town of Simsville Colorado, breaking in a new case keeper by the name of Jim Higginson to assist him in running his faro games. But when they have an extraordinarily successful night against a gang leader named Joshua, the gang chooses to regain their losses by torturing both Blake and young Higginson for the location of the hidden cash. Higginson gives up the location but does not survive the torture. This launches Blake on a vendetta to regain his earnings and destroy the gang. He is aided by Higginson’s sister as Blake infiltrates the gang by assuming the guise of a notorious bank robber and safe cracker. Of course, things don’t go as planned, especially when the real bank robber shows up, but watching Blake get out of all the precarious predicaments is half the fun.

This book is packed full of western action, adventurous escapades, exciting gun play, and a fair amount of sexual shenanigans, fulfilling its mission as an “adult western.” The prose is lean and the plot moves along at a rapid pace, keeping me turning the pages. At times it feels like the author’s comic book experience shines through here as well. Faro Blake proves to be a welcome protagonist; easy to ride in his boots even if he makes different choices than I would.

Borden Chantry by Louis L'Amour

Besides the Sacketts, Louis L’Amour also wrote other family sagas with multiple books associated with them, most prominently, books featuring either the Chantry or Talon families.  In fact, all three families tie-in together through events, marriage, etc., making these books even more interesting.

Here, Borden Chantry has had some bad luck with ranching so has been working as town marshal to earn a little money to provide for his wife and son, Tom (who features in "North to the Rails"). Serving as marshal is not Borden’s heart’s desire but like most L’Amour heroes, he strives to do a good job and earn the money he is paid. So, when the body of a dead man is found shot to death, he is not content to merely chalk it up to a drunken brawl or a bad card game and simply have the man buried. He needs to find the killer. More murders occur and it becomes increasingly evident that Borden is also targeted.

The story turns into much more of a whodunnit detective novel than the typical L’Amour western novel although plenty of western action remains. When Borden eventually identifies the dead man, it turns out to be none other than Joe Sackett, younger brother of Orrin, Tell, and Tyrel. Later on, Tyrel makes a nice cameo appearance, developing a relationship with Borden. They would work together again in "Son of a Wanted Man". I love it when characters from other L’Amour books show up when I least expect it. Additionally, the character of Kim Baca is first introduced here.

All in all, I really enjoyed this one. The mystery elements are well handled as are the expected western gunfights. Borden is a likable character, a little less perfect and more like us than most of this author’s protagonists. Despite his skill with a gun, he doesn’t really think he’s cut out to be marshal, much less a detective, but he perseveres anyway.